cape vinyards from long ago

Home
Cultivating in good hope
The Mystic Harvest
The Lie of the Land
Empowerment
Taming the Terroir
Image is everything
The Devil's Harvest
Vineyard Vignettes
Bibliography

Contact the National
Library of South Africa
Credits &
Site Messages
cape vineyards from long ago


From left to right (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. The slave bell in the Dutch East India Company gardens where the first vines were planted in the Cape. This picture was taken in c1930. [409]
2. The slave bell at the Meerlust wine farm. The cover of Landbou-weekblad (an agricultural weekly) in 1952. [413]

 

A typical feature of the classic Cape-Dutch farm house is the twin-pillared arch supporting the slave bell – a stark reminder of the generations of slaves many of whom were of the Muslim faith - who built the Cape wine industry during the Dutch and British colonial eras.
A detailed history of slavery [146]

The early Cape vineyards were particularly closely spaced, more in keeping with viticultural practices in the cold wine-producing countries of the Northern Hemisphere than with practices more suited to the hotter regions of the South. These closely planted vineyards had major political consequences for South Africa: due to this narrow spacing the vineyards could not be tilled by animals and therefore required manual digging. For this purpose slaves, as the cheapest form of labour, were brought to the Cape to work the vineyards. [69] The society that emerged at the Cape as a result of colonial expansion was characterized by the violent exploitation both of imported slaves and of indigenous labour, in this way improving levels of agrarian production and at the same time entrenching the distribution of power and wealth along racial lines.

Click on thumbnail to enlarge
Estimating slave productivity on the wine farms [146]


From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. A dissertation on the link between slavery and wine production [193]
2. A summary of the dissertation researching the link between slavery and wine production. A field where information is sparse. [193]
Although slavery was formally abolished in 1834, the coercive practices developed to constrain emancipated slaves - and to continue the economic viability of the Cape’s wine farms - had important legacies for rural social relations in South Africa. The lives of farm labourers continued to be dominated by exploitation and paternalism.


From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. A remarkable book published in 1989: “Cape wine labourers are an anachronism, trapped in a vicious past. Historians have remarked that little change has taken place in their conditions since slavery was abolished 150 years ago” Quote from page 4. [145]
2. Cover design by Jan Brown [145]
3. Seasonal workers and their children on a farm near Paarl in the Cape. Photo: Orde Eliason [145]
4. A seasonal worker moves his bed to lodgings on the next door farm near Wellington in the Cape. March 1986. Photo: Orde Eliason [145]
5. A catering team unloading fare for the guests at a wine auction and a farm labourer and his daughter near Klawer in the Namaqualand. Photo: Orde Eliason [145]


Recent research into child labour - June 2001 [241]
According to Rayner, until recently, the labour system on wine farms appeared “to be grounded in a combination of derisory wages, tied housing, chronic indebtedness, alcohol addiction and social relationships marked by deference and racism”. [193] While initiatives such as the Rural Foundation (founded in 1982) attempted to address some of these concerns and effect the upliftment of farm workers [140], it was not until new legislation was enacted in the 1990’s, that farm workers were protected by law and were able to mobilise and organise themselves. [195] [197] [196] [252]

From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. Thandiwe's story [241]
2. Itinerant wine workers on the Paarl Road in November 1929 [366]

 

From left to right:
1. A para-legal guide published in 1998 [198]
2. The section on "Payment in kind". There is no reference to the "dop" system [198a]

On May Day 1993, the Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997 [417] was extended to include farm workers for the first time in South Africa. Farm workers are now further protected by both the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 [418] and the Extension of Security of Tenure Act 63 of 1997 [419]. The latter gives them occupational rights on the farm where they have worked and lived. Since 1998 the lives of farm workers have also been positively affected by both the Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 [420] and the Skills Development Act 97 of 1998 [421].
There have been many transformations on wine farms in the past decade and opportunities are opening up for farm workers to acquire a stake in the industry, albeit amid some criticism. In 1997, the Farm Workers’ Association Western Cape [247] was formed to promote the interests of the farm worker communities and to give them a representative voice which empowers them to speak on their own behalf on various relevant platforms. [346]

The “Dop” System and its legacy

One legacy of slave labour on the Cape’s wine farms is the ‘dop’ system, the payment of farm workers with alcohol in place of wages, and it is a seemingly tenacious feature of South African agriculture.

The “dop” system originated in the early years of colonial settlement at the Cape when indigenous people were induced, by the European farm-owners, to work on farms in return for payment with tobacco, bread and wine. This tradition of giving out wine in return for labour became entrenched in farming practice at the Cape over the next 300 years and formed an important element of the social control exercised over farm labourers.

From left to right:
1. Ralph Bunche, Nobel Peace Prizewinner in 1950, visited South Africa in 1937/38. The published travel notes of his visit includes a poem on the "dop" system by Eddie Roux. [147]
2. A poem by Eddie Roux, member of the S.A. Communist Party and editor of "Umsebenzi" the communist weekly newspaper [147]


From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. A 1953 photograph - the "dop" was given up to five times a day on some farms [365]
2. The "dop" or "tot" system [392]
3. A journal in 1939 advertising a "labourer's barrel" for the storing of "dop" wine. [353]


From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. Liquor Act 30 of 1928 [203]
2. The provisions of the Act that embodied the "dop" system in law [203]

It is of interest to note that until 1928 it was left it up to the farm owner to determine how and at what times wine would be supplied to the farm’s labourers. However, in 1928 when the Liquor Act [203] was amended, it was decided to bring about a change in the pattern of supply of wine to labourers. Section 96(2) of the Act determined how, when and how much wine could be supplied during the day. In this way the “dop” system became embodied in the law and was only officially outlawed in the 1960’s.

 

From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. The Commission of Enquiry into the supply of liquor [201]
2. The Commission's recommendations on the "dop" system [201]

 


Opposition to the tot goes back a long way, from the Temperance agitation of the 1840’s and the Synod of the Dutch Reformed Church in 1915 through various legislation and commission reports. As early as 1928 legislators called for the curtailment of the dop system [203] by legislating its supply and, following the recommendations of the Malan Commission of Enquiry in 1960, it was eventually outlawed. [201] [245]

 

 

From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. A summary of a recent study on the prevalence of the "dop" system [244]
2. A table of the results of the study of the prevalence of the "dop" system done in 1998 [244]

Yet literature on the subject records that the system is still in use on farms in the region. [244] While the formal application of the “dop” system has declined in recent years, the associated legacy of alcohol abuse continues.

The adverse impacts of the “dop” system and its resultant alcohol abuse, in terms of health and development, are substantial among farming communities in the Western Cape. Indeed the Western Cape Government’s 1994 Draft Provincial Health Plan identified alcohol abuse as one of the most significant rural health priorities in a province where alcohol-related trauma, exceptionally high rates of TB, child and adult malnutrition, and the incidence of foetal alcohol syndrome (FAS), are common. Foetal Alcohol Syndrome is the result of alcohol abuse during pregnancy and children born with FAS are noted for growth deficiencies, other recognisable physical symptoms, and mental retardation. The disorder is the most easily preventable form of mental retardation globally. In fact, Foetal Alcohol Syndrome is so prevalent in the Western Cape [250] that there are suggestions that the province may have the highest incidence worldwide.

From left to right: (Click on thumbnail to enlarge)
1. There is good reason to think that the highest incidence of Foetal Alcohol Syndrome exists in the Western Cape [246]
2. A recent petition against illegal wine sales to farm workers [246]

In addition, there is a legacy of social problems associated with alcohol abuse, such as child abuse, violence against women and family violence. However, according to the July 2002 English version of Riette Rust’s article based on conversations with community leaders, from the wineland.co.za website community leaders in the wine industry say that the causes of current social conditions on farms are more complex than just the effect of the “dop” system. In Rust’s article, these leaders note that farm workers are on the whole excluded from the wine industry’s decision-making structures as well as from provincial transport, health, sport and educational budgets. These leaders further note that farm workers lack an established organisation through which to speak with a united voice.

The "dop" legacy lives on - March 1999
[242]

Various stakeholders are tackling the legacy of the “dop” system and its related issues and below are some of the projects aimed at redressing the system: In 1995 a group of nurses from the Cape Metropolitan Council (CMC), now amalgamated into the City of Cape Town running mobile clinics in the Stellenbosch rural farming region, decided to wage war against the “dop” system because of its health implications. From this DOPSTOP was started in 1997 to fight the ‘‘dop” system and its effects. More recently the Dopstop Association, campaigning for the improvement of the social conditions of farm workers on the wine farms, has adopted a new approach whereby both farm workers and farm owners are involved in the decision making to reach set goals. These goals include the prevention of alcohol abuse and the reduction of excessive alcohol consumption by providing social alternatives and by raising awareness of the hazards associated with alcohol abuse. [301]

The South African wine industry too has responded to the issue of alcohol abuse. According to an article in the Cape Argus, 17 May 2002, the industry has pledged R71 million (about $7.18 million) over ten years to support FAS research, fund alcohol-abuse prevention programmes and help vineyard workers start their own farms. [360]

The South African Wine Industry Trust [346] has also made generous contributions to FAS research. In January 1997 the Foundation for Alcohol Related Research (FARR) was formed under the Chairmanship of Professor Denis VIljoen at the University of the Witwatersrand. The South African National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependance (SANCA) have also initiated projects, aimed at the prevention of FAS, in conjunction with local and international bodies.